Yes , It Does : A Diatribe on Jerry Fodor ’ s The Mind Doesn ’ t Work that Way
نویسنده
چکیده
The Mind Doesn’t Work That Way is an expose of certain theoretical problems in cognitive science, and in particular, problems that concern the Classical Computational Theory of Mind (CTM). The problems that Fodor worries plague CTM divide into two kinds, and both purport to show that the success of cognitive science will likely be limited to the modules. The first sort of problem concerns what Fodor has called “global properties”; features that a mental sentence has which depend on how the sentence interacts with a larger plan (i.e., set of sentences), rather than the type identity of the sentence alone. The second problem concerns what many have called, “The Relevance Problem”: the problem of whether and how humans determine what is relevant in a computational manner. However, I argue that the problem that Fodor believes global properties pose for CTM is a non-problem, and that further, while the relevance problem is a serious research issue, it does not justify the grim view that cognitive science, and CTM in particular, will likely fail to explain cognition.
منابع مشابه
Fodor ’ s Challenge to the Classical Computational Theory of Mind KIRK
In The Mind Doesn ’ t Work That Way , Jerry Fodor argues that mental representations have context sensitive features relevant to cognition, and that, therefore, the Classical Computational Theory of Mind (CTM) is mistaken. We call this the Globality Argument. This is an in principle argument against CTM. We argue that it is self-defeating. We consider an alternative argument constructed from ma...
متن کاملA critical review of Jerry A . Fodor ’ s The mind doesn ’ t work that way
The “New Synthesis” in cognitive science is committed to the computational theory of mind (CTM), massive modularity, nativism, and adaptationism. In The mind doesn’t work that way, Jerry Fodor argues that CTM has problems explaining abductive or global inference, but that the New Synthesis offers no solution, since massive modularity is in fact incompatible with global cognitive processes. I ar...
متن کاملHierarchy helps it work that way
Jerry Fodor argues, in The mind doesn’t work that way (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2000), that the computational theory of mind is undermined by the pervasive context sensitivity of human cognition. His objections can be easily met, however, by noting the properties of appropriately structured representation hierarchies. In The mind doesn’t work that way (Fodor, 2000) Jerry Fodor argues that the ...
متن کاملAre we wrong about representation?
In his recent book, The Elm and The Expert (1994), Jerry Fodor opens with a rather puzzling remark: “It may be that I have gotten myself into a philosophical situation about which all that can helpfully be said is that I ought not to have gotten myself into it” (p.1). Fodor is referring to what is a paradoxical and deep problem in his theory concerning the relations between representational con...
متن کاملFodor ' S Guide to Mental Representation : the Intelligent Auntie ' S Vade -mecum
pull the cat' s tail . It was going to be an awful afternoon until Uncle Wilifred thought of Mental Representations (which was a game that we hadn ' t played for years) and everybody got very excited and we jumped up and down and waved our hands and all talked at once and had a perfectly lovely romp . But Auntie said that she couldn 't stand the noise and there would be tears before bedtime if ...
متن کامل